Hollow Harvests: higher yields, lower levels of some nutrients in many crops
The report brings together long-term nutrient comparisons. Separate studies examine the roles of carbon dioxide and farm management.
Source: 2026-10-06 · Published here: 2026-11-03
Short version
Higher yields do not guarantee higher nutrient concentrations. Deep Science Ventures’ Hollow Harvests report brings together evidence of 20–50% declines in selected nutrients across many crops over several decades. These figures refer to particular comparisons. They do not mean that every food lost half of its total nutritional value.
Responses include breeding for quality alongside yield, protecting soil function and measuring the final product. Studies link nutrient composition to elevated carbon dioxide and to farm management. Brix provides a quick measure of soluble solids for field comparisons. Iron, zinc and other nutrients require separate analysis.
Full analysis
Agriculture needs to measure the nutrition it produces as well as the tonnes it harvests. Hollow Harvests argues for making nutrient density a criterion in crop improvement. In its official presentation, Deep Science Ventures, working with the Mark Leonard Trust, links declines in selected nutrients to the emphasis on yield and calls for changes in varieties and management.
The figures and how to read them
- 20–50%: declines in several individual nutrients across many crops in the comparisons assembled by the report.
- 215%: the increase in cereal yield per hectare since the 1960s, according to the official presentation.
- More than two billion people have at least one clinical micronutrient deficiency, according to the same source.
The report synthesises evidence and makes proposals. Here we use its public presentation and the individual studies listed below. Different nutrients are measured separately, and the percentages do not describe a general loss of nutritional value for every vegetable.
Carbon dioxide can change nutrient composition
Myers and colleagues in Nature studied crops grown in open-air carbon dioxide enrichment experiments at concentrations expected by mid-century. Zinc and iron concentrations fell in C3 cereals and legumes. Protein also fell in non-legume C3 crops, while C4 crops were less affected.
Harvard’s account reports 9.3% less zinc, 5.1% less iron and 6.3% less protein in wheat compared with crops grown at ambient concentrations. These are experimental results under specific conditions and differ from the report’s historical comparisons.
What comparisons of regenerative farms show
Montgomery and colleagues in PeerJ compared pairs of US farms under conventional management and under regenerative practices used for 5–10 years. They recorded differences in soil health and crop nutrient density. This was a preliminary comparison on working farms, with outcomes varying by product and nutrient. It does not establish a fixed percentage gain for every field changing management.
The practical value is that the study examines the soil and the crop together. High yield, a good organic matter reading or the name of a farming system cannot by themselves describe the crop’s composition. Both soil and crop need to be measured.
Soil microbiology needs attention
Soil organisms break down organic residues, recycle nutrients and form symbiotic relationships with roots. The FAO links soil biodiversity to plant nutrition, soil structure and water regulation. Maintaining living roots, supplying organic material and avoiding unnecessary disturbance help protect these functions.
Where Brix is useful
A refractometer measures soluble solids in a juice sample. In fruit, much of this is sugar, and the reading is used to assess ripeness and sweetness. Brix offers a practical way to make repeated comparisons when variety, plant part, maturity and sampling method are kept consistent.
The reading does not give separate concentrations of iron, zinc, protein or vitamins. Linking a Brix change to the nutritional value of the same product requires parallel laboratory testing. This gives a quick field observation a sounder basis.
A practical proposal
Run a simple comparison in the same field using the same variety, a common harvest stage and replicates. Record yield, Brix, water management and soil management, and send representative samples for analysis of the nutrients of interest. This helps base decisions on the nutrition that the harvest actually delivers.
Sources and further reading
- Deep Science Ventures: official presentation of Hollow Harvests
- DSV: dated publication listing, 6 October 2026
- Myers et al., Nature (2014), DOI 10.1038/nature13179
- Harvard: quantitative results of the experiment
- Montgomery et al., PeerJ (2022), DOI 10.7717/peerj.12848
- FAO: soil biodiversity
- FAO: soluble solids and refractometry