Why did Canada remove guano from organic farming? The risks behind a natural fertiliser

Source date: 2026-03-26 · First published in Greek: 2026-11-12

Διαβάστε στα ελληνικά

Short version

Full version →
Synthetic narration · Bella, Kokoro-82M

A fertiliser can come from nature and still fall short of organic farming requirements. Canada’s March 2026 standards illustrate this by removing guano, the accumulated droppings of wild bats and birds, from the list of permitted crop production inputs.

The Organic Federation of Canada identifies three main concerns. Some deposits can contain toxic metals, the material can carry pathogens, and harvesting can disturb bat and seabird colonies. A separate Canadian assessment in 2026 considered risks from bat guano, including the fungus that causes white-nose syndrome.

Canada has prohibited imports of bat guano since 2014. The newer change concerns guano use in organic crop production, with a transition for existing operators. Some phosphate rock can originate from ancient mineralised guano and is assessed under separate rules.

In the European Union, guano remains on the list of permitted organic inputs, subject to additional legal requirements. The case raises a basic question for growers: how should we assess the origin, production and impacts of a natural fertiliser?

Full version

Short version ↑
Synthetic narration · Bella, Kokoro-82M

A natural fertiliser under Canada’s revised standard

In March 2026, Canada published its revised organic standard CAN/CGSB-32.311-2026. Guano is no longer listed as a permitted input for organic crops. The Organic Materials Review Institute (OMRI) and the explanatory guide from the Organic Federation of Canada (OFC) and Canadian Organic Growers (COG) confirm the change. Certified operators generally have up to one year to adapt. The decision reflects concerns about safety, origin and ecological effects alongside the fertiliser’s ability to supply nutrients.

What is guano?

Guano consists of accumulated droppings from wild bats and birds, especially seabirds. Depending on origin and degree of decomposition or mineralisation, it can supply nitrogen and phosphorus. Its composition varies. It can be sold as a relatively recent deposit or as a very old mineralised material. Manure from farmed poultry belongs to a different category unless it actually meets the applicable definition.

Potential soil contamination

OFC notes that some guano products can contain toxic metals. These can accumulate in soil with repeated application. Contamination varies with the deposit, so provenance and laboratory characterisation matter when assessing the suitability of a product.

Biosecurity, pathogens and antimicrobial resistance

Deposits may contain microorganisms relevant to human or wildlife health. In 2026 the Public Health Agency of Canada examined the risks of importing bat guano, including potential spread of the fungus associated with white-nose syndrome and risks associated with antimicrobial resistance. For infection of bats through imported guano under a hypothetical lifting of the ban, it estimated a moderate to high likelihood with high uncertainty due to data gaps. The assessment distinguished exposure routes and affected populations and assessed different microorganisms separately.

Canada’s prohibition on imports of bat guano has applied since 2014 and also covers products containing it. A narrow exception applies to clean, unprocessed guano under a special scientific research permit. The import prohibition and the 2026 organic standards change apply to different activities.

Protection of bats and seabirds

Harvesting can involve entering caves or working in bird breeding areas. Disturbance, lighting, noise and changes in microclimate can threaten sensitive colonies. Cave guano also supports whole communities of organisms, so removing it can have ecological consequences.

Mineralised deposits and EU rules

The Canadian guide notes that some ancient, fully mineralised deposits resemble phosphate rock. Phosphate rock remains a separate entry with its own conditions. The material’s actual identity, origin and legal classification must be documented.

The consolidated text of EU Implementing Regulation 2021/1165 as of 1 January 2026 still lists guano in Annex II among fertilisers and soil conditioners allowed for organic production. Use of a particular product remains subject to applicable EU and national law, notably rules on fertilisers and animal by-products. The label alone is insufficient.

Implications for organic and regenerative farming

Safety, agronomic need, traceability and compatibility with living soils all matter. Before using a soil amendment, consider crop and soil needs, analyses and product provenance. Well-produced compost, plant residues and cover crops can be part of the strategy, with evidence and a suitable nutrient plan. Eligibility under organic rules, safety and ecological regeneration each require their own assessment.

Sources

  1. organicfederation.ca
  2. publications.gc.ca
  3. cog.ca
  4. omri.org
  5. Public Health Agency of Canada, One Health risk analysis, 9/1/2026
  6. Canada Border Services Agency, Customs Notice 24-04: Import Prohibition on Bat Guano
  7. eur-lex.europa.eu
  8. regenerative.gr