Compost and biochar: can they build soil carbon while helping to suppress plant diseases?
A scientific review examines how compost and biochar may support soil carbon storage and suppress soil-borne pathogens, while showing why material quality and field-specific evidence matter.
Can compost and biochar improve soil carbon storage while also helping protect crops from soil-borne pathogens? A review published on 7 November 2026 in the Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition examines the mechanisms linking these two goals.
The researchers describe complementary pathways. Mature compost adds organic matter and can support microbial communities that compete with disease-causing organisms. Biochar, produced by heating biomass under oxygen-limited conditions, can introduce relatively persistent forms of carbon and porous surfaces that influence water and nutrient retention and microbial habitats.
The review identifies promising evidence, but it does not show that every compost or biochar product suppresses every disease. Results depend on the amendment's quality, soil type and pH, pathogen species and growing conditions. Immature or contaminated materials can also cause harm, making quality checks essential.
For regenerative agriculture, the decisive question is not simply what goes into the soil, but what changes afterwards. Soil organic carbon, aggregation, biological activity, root health and actual disease incidence all need monitoring.
Two challenges with a shared biological foundation
Losses of soil organic carbon and diseases originating in the soil are often studied separately. Yet soil structure, organic matter, water dynamics and microbial communities influence both. A new review in the Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition examines how organic amendments may help stabilize carbon while supporting the biological suppression of plant pathogens.
Published on 7 November 2026, the paper synthesizes existing research; it is not a new field experiment demonstrating one universal outcome across crops. That distinction matters when translating findings from the scientific literature into decisions on a farm.
Compost and the living soil
Mature, quality-controlled compost contributes organic materials and can support a diverse community of soil organisms. Under some conditions, members of those communities compete with pathogens for nutrients and space or produce compounds that inhibit their activity.
This is the basis of a disease-suppressive soil: disease severity is reduced through the functioning of the soil ecosystem as a whole, or through the action of particular microbial groups. The word “compost” alone tells us little about whether a material will achieve this. Maturity, hygienic safety and biological properties are separate qualities that must be assessed.
What biochar contributes
Biochar is made by heating biomass with limited oxygen. Its properties vary according to the feedstock and production temperature. It can contain relatively persistent forms of carbon, while its porous structure and surface chemistry may influence water and nutrient retention, soil pH and microbial habitats.
The review cites studies in which specially modified biochars were associated with substantial reductions in particular plant diseases. One example involved silicon-modified biochar and a reported 73.4% reduction in a bacterial-wilt disease index associated with Ralstonia solanacearum. That figure belongs to a specific experimental setting. It is not a performance claim for biochar in general.
Why combining the two is worth investigating
Compost can supply comparatively accessible organic compounds and support biological processes. Biochar can contribute more persistent carbon and a different set of physical and chemical surfaces. Researchers are therefore interested in their combined use, especially where the goals include soil fertility, structural improvement and crop resilience.
But a mixture is not automatically better in every field. On alkaline soils, for example, applying strongly alkaline biochar could push pH in an undesirable direction. Immature compost or contaminated feedstocks may also introduce phytotoxic compounds, salts, heavy metals or unwanted microorganisms. The review highlights these risks and calls for more long-term field evidence.
What this means for regenerative management
Adding an amendment does not, by itself, prove that soil has been regenerated. A credible assessment begins with baseline measurements and follows changes in soil organic carbon, aggregation, water infiltration and retention, pH, nutrient availability, functional biological activity, root condition and disease incidence.
In an olive grove or vegetable field, different treatments should be compared with suitable controls, with soil characteristics and weather recorded alongside the results. A Soil Food Web perspective can help examine biological mechanisms, but measurements of microbial communities do not replace direct observations of crop health and performance.
The conclusion: Compost and biochar are promising, potentially complementary tools. Their value depends on material quality and measurable outcomes in a specific soil, not on the name of the practice.
Sources and further reading
- Ullah Q. et al. (2026), “Organic Amendments for Simultaneous Soil Carbon Sequestration and Soil-Borne Pathogen Suppression: Mechanisms and Perspectives,” Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, published 7 November 2026. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42729-026-03665-z
- Adetunji A. T. and Blanco-Canqui H. (2026), “Soil health response to biochar combined with other amendments: a review,” Biochar. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42773-025-00531-6
- Zhao Z. et al. (2026), “Biochar for sustainable crop production,” Nature Reviews Earth & Environment. https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-026-00847-2